“Stay out of his life.”
The first trailer for the Sopranos prequel movie The Many Saints of Newark is now out, and it promises a new and unique take on the world of the beloved HBO mob series. Set in the late ’60s and early ’70s, Many Saints will tell the story of Dickie Moltisanti (Alessandro Nivola), the father of the show’s Christopher Moltisanti who we only ever heard stories of from Tony and Chrissy prior to this.
Judging by the trailer for Many Saints of Newark, however, a young Tony Soprano will play a larger role in the film than fans might’ve expected, with the late James Gandolfini’s son Michael taking on the part from his dad. We spoke to the film’s director Alan Taylor, who also helmed some of the greatest episodes of the show (“Kennedy and Heidi”… oof), about how Many Saints connects Dickie’s world to Tony’s, what it was like casting Michael Gandolfini, and much more.
[ignvideo url=”https://www.ign.com/videos/2021/06/29/the-many-saints-of-newark-official-trailer”]
A Dickie Moltisanti Movie or a Tony Soprano Movie?
It was intriguing that when the oft-rumored, seemingly unlikely Sopranos movie was finally announced, it was revealed that Dickie Moltisanti would be the central character. Christopher, who was Tony’s “nephew” and heir apparent on the show, never knew his father, who died when he was just a baby.
Despite the prominence of young Tony in the trailer, Taylor says that the new film is “absolutely Dickie’s story.
“He is, in my mind anyway, a kind of classic Sopranos man for all kinds of reasons, and that’s why we can explore all the same themes and tones through him that we know from the show,” says Taylor.
At the same time, the marketing department has to sell the movie, just as they have to sell any other movie, and so tying Dickie to the more familiar aspects of The Sopranos is integral to the film’s success. (Cue the “Woke Up This Morning” theme song.)
“I think our interest in him, and… the audience’s interest in him, comes from the fact that he is the guy that most shaped the guy we all know and have a complex relationship to,” says Taylor.
Taylor later elaborated: “So to make that connection [to the audience] and convey this basic idea, we thought, ‘Okay, you know Tony. Or at least you’ve heard about him. What you don’t know is that this is the guy that made him who he is. And we’re going to tell you his story.’ So there is a kind of handoff within the trailer.”
[widget path=”global/article/imagegallery” parameters=”slug=the-many-saints-of-newark-whos-who-in-the-sopranos-prequel-movie&captions=true”]
Indeed, we always knew that Dickie was a very important presence in Tony’s life and development. The show always gave the impression that Dickie was a mentor to Tony as much as Tony was a mentor to Christopher, and that Tony had an undying affection for him even all these years after Dickie’s death. (And by the way, Taylor promises that we will find out the full story of Dickie’s fate in the movie.)
“His relationship to Tony is key, for him and for Tony,” says the director. “But all of our stories in the movie, and there’s a few, all are grounded in Dickie. So his relationship with Harold, this character that Leslie Odom is playing, and the conflict between them — it’s very much Dickie’s conflict. And there’s a love story with this wonderful actress. And Dickie’s relationship to Ray Liotta is a huge part of the movie. So it’s all very Dickie-centric, but our way in, and even the way the movie starts is sort of taking us through Tony to Dickie.”
Which brings us to that last line in the trailer when Ray Liotta’s character says to Dickie, “Stay out of his life.”
“That is one of my favorite lines in the trailer,” says Taylor. “And I’m glad they ended it there, because what we’re saying is, ‘This relationship shaped Tony more than any others, and the best advice this guy got was to stay away from Tony.’ So it’s a loving family relationship, but it’s a loving family relationship in the Sopranos’ world. So…”
Casting Michael Gandolfini as Tony Soprano
The sad passing of James Gandolfini in 2013 seemed at the time to mean that a return to the Sopranos world in some form was unlikely (the series had ended in 2007). But the prequel setting of The Many Saints of Newark also gave Taylor and Sopranos creator David Chase, who also wrote the film with Lawrence Konner, a unique opportunity to cast Gandolfini’s son Michael in the role. It was also a stressful proposition for the director to make a Sopranos story without James.
“That was central to our conceiving of the movie, I think, and sort of like a touchstone in a way,” says Taylor. “And it’s not like we jumped off immediately and did that. We had been actively looking for the youngest Tony and for the more teenage Tony. But this idea was always sort of hovering there as a possibility for Michael before we even knew if he’d be comfortable doing it or interested. And then when we did decide to go that way, we put him through the ringer. We made him come in and audition and show that he could do it. And I was really happy with the audition he gave, but there was also this wave of, ‘My God, this is so the right thing to do.’”
Even the glimpses we get of Michael’s take on “teenage Tony” in the trailer indicate a performance that just might do what might’ve seemed impossible — to recreate the intense presence and aura of James Gandolfini’s Tony Soprano.
“In our dinner, before we started shooting, [Michael] stood up and said he wanted to thank everybody for this chance to say hello to his father again, and goodbye again,” recalls Taylor. “And everybody fell off their chairs. But I think he became sort of the heart of the movie for us. And it made us feel like we were doing something right by having him there. He seemed to enjoy it and rise to the occasion. And there’s a few moments in the movie where you sort of see him become the character we know from the show. It’s really compelling.”
Of course, as the director says, you can’t tell Tony’s story without his mom being a big part of it. And Vera Farmiga is here as Livia Soprano, the complicated character from the show with an even more complicated relationship with her son. Taylor said that he actually shot more with Farmiga that didn’t make it into the theatrical cut of the film, and that he’d love to do an extended version at some point with that extra footage.
“There was some wonderful stuff that helps [you] understand her inner psychology,” he says. “But some of that fell by the wayside. She’s very important in his life. You get the dynamic [in the theatrical cut]. She’s younger and beautiful, and you still see a kind of flirty energy between her and [Tony’s dad] Johnny — in between the smashing plates and throwing pots and trying to shoot each other! You see this younger couple and why he was attracted to her. And you get a moment with her where you… It’s really sort of heartbreaking. The mothering impulse is there too, but you see this is before it was totally sort of curdled as time went on.”
[poilib element=”quoteBox” parameters=”excerpt=Dickie%20is%20somebody%20who%26%2339%3Bs%20really%20trying%20to%20change%20his%20cycle%2C%20and%20trying%20to%20change%20his%20destiny.”]
Taylor also drops some hints about the film that will surely have fans looking back at episodes of the show in a new light: “She has a crush on Dickie sort of, because Dickie is sort of the elegant one. And Junior can be jealous of the fact that Livia and Tony both seem to like Dickie more than him.” But also, Livia’s trajectory fits into the bigger scheme of Many Saints’ story and themes, including Dickie’s arc. “Dickie is somebody who’s really trying to change his cycle, and trying to change his destiny,” says Taylor.
“I think some people sort of drive each other crazier over time,” says Taylor. “And I think she and Johnny had a relationship that sort of curdled both of them. But it’s nice to see the glimpses that could have gone the other way. Livia didn’t have to turn out like Livia. We see a very concrete moment that could have changed Livia’s story in the movie. And Tony and Dickie are both involved in that. These people we know… We think we know who they are. This is just a reminder that it didn’t have to go that way, or did it sort of have to go to that? It’s the question of how locked in are we?”
The Many Saints of Newark will be released in theaters in the US on October 1 and will be available on HBO Max 31 days from the theatrical release.